News   Forum   Reviews   Articles   Where to Shop   Links   Polls   Submit News   DAP Shop  
iPod Shuffle vs. Luxpro Super Tangent Battle-Review
comment: 11 | Monday, August 01 (2005) 01:47AM | Posted by Austin Vaughan


CNET Asia has a dual-review of the iPod Shuffle compared to Luxpro's knock-off player, the Super Tangent. As you might have guessed...

"The shuffle wins the confrontation this time, proving that sometimes, copycats just can't hold a candle to the original. But if faced off against an MP3 player that sports its own screen, the results could possibly be the other way around."

They felt the Shuffle had greater build quality and controls, better sound quality, longer battery life, a wider range of codec support (Apple's closed formats - AAC and Apple Lossless), and of course, there are more accessories available. The tangent only won in two sections out of the seven that were presented, namely, for its ease of use and extra features (voice recording, FM radio, bass boost). Read the whole bit HERE.


Thanks, axel
Comments

scottder

Comments: 185
Aug 01 (2005) 06:51AM  

Since when AAC a "closed" format?




Austin Vaughan
Location: Lenexa, KS
Comments: 768
Aug 01 (2005) 07:17AM  

tracks i bought in iTunes only play on my iPod. i call that "closed"






Dominic
Location: Ireland.
Comments: 2396
Aug 01 (2005) 07:30AM  

its about as closed as WMA, so yeah i'd probably call it a closed format too




Lone

Comments: 973
Aug 01 (2005) 08:13AM  

Well, it's 'closed' 'cause even tracks ripped in AAC play on iPod, and only maybe one or two other players.




Sebhelyesfarku

Comments: 398
Aug 01 (2005) 11:29AM  

Apple's DRM is closed not AAC itself




MrXero

Guest
Aug 01 (2005) 01:38PM  

<quote>Both the shuffle and Tangent use an LED light embedded above the center control keys to indicate the status of the MP3 player, though the shuffle uses two instead of one as in the case of the Tangent.</quote>The Tangent has two LEDs just like the Shuffle only the green one is very weak. Show's how thorough CNet Asia is.




MrXero

Guest
Aug 01 (2005) 01:48PM  

Not to mention they only design flaw they got nit-picky about is the friggin usb cap. The design score should have been a draw. I don't understand how CNet can always favor Apple.




Fryhole

Comments: 137
Aug 01 (2005) 03:17PM  

Is it just me, or is this review, shootout, whatever you want to call it, waaaaaay longer than most of the ones on the ol' cnet.com?




earthtoandy

Guest
Aug 01 (2005) 05:06PM  

AAC is in no way closed. It is an open format as part of MPEG-4. Apple neither invented it nor owns it. AAC files will play on any device that chooses to support it. The DRM that is placed on the AAC files by the iTunes music store is proprietary as is ALL DRM technology which these files are required to have to be sold. What is hard to understand about that.

People should try to not give out misinformation and then redistribute it again




SowndOfDeth

Comments: 417
Aug 02 (2005) 02:33AM  

Well AAC is like a closed format. The number of players that can play AAC are limited.
I have all my collection in mp3 anyway




Anonymous

Guest
Aug 02 (2005) 03:06AM  

Technically, AAC is not a closed format, it's as open as MP3, just not as supported. However, Apple's music store is closed, and as that's what most people associate AAC with, it does get confusticating..




You must be logged in to make comments on this site - please log in, or if you are not registered click here to signup







User Reviews   Privacy Policy