News   Forum   Reviews   Articles   Where to Shop   Links   Polls   Submit News   DAP Shop  
Hard-Fi: rip from CD to MP3 player the easy way
comment: 8 | Friday, September 09 (2005) 11:04AM | Posted by Austin Vaughan
Ashley of techdigest.tv brought this nifty gadget to my attention. The Hard-Fi is a set-top box that makes it a one-touch operation to rip a CD to MP3, tag all the tracks (with a built-in CDDB database), and load it on an MP3 player via USB. I doubt any of you guys need such a thing but I imagine it would pretty useful for people who struggle with technology. Like my mom, who can't even figure out the iPod I got her for Christmas. Ugh. So there's bound be at least 5.9 billion humans who could use a thing like this. The only problem I forsee is that these kind of devices are usually priced beyond what thier functionality would suggest and beyond what most of us would pay. It's probably just a bare-bones linux system in there with some kind of script for ripping, tagging, and transferring.
As for when or where you could get one, it's not exactley clear. One page mentions that the first product with the system is already available (see pic) but it fails to give you any of the particulars. Ah well. We'll keep an eye out.

HardFi.org via techdigest.tv

UPDATE: ok, so they had the file name of that picture labled sp150.jpg and a bit of google'n turns up the Acoustic Solutions SP150. A review at digitalhomemag.com details its ripping ability (to an internal hard drive) but doesn't mention the ability to download directly to an MP3 player, so I'm guessing that feature probably hasn't been implemented in any production model yet. Somebody, get to it.
Comments

UK Rio Engineer

Comments: 13
Sep 09 (2005) 12:26PM  

The Rio Central ripped to HDD and allowed transfer to (Rio) MP3 players back in 2002. It'd even encode 2 versions concurrently - high bitrate for the unit itself, and a low bitrate copy for the portable - to make the most of the small players that were around at the time. It'd even serve 8 Rio Receiver thin clients and burn CDs too.

Still, that's what you get for being too far ahead of the curve I guess!





dan325it

Comments: 58
Sep 09 (2005) 01:00PM  

I'm an expert on Luddites -- my wife can't figure out how to attach photos to an email. "See there, that button that says 'Attach Files'?" I guarantee you she couldn't figure this out.

This is exactly what I've been looking for -- a replacement for my 400-CD jukebox that takes up half my AV space and weighs a quarter ton. Except it's been so totally screwed up. Imagine a mp3 jukebox/cd player that can't read mp3 cd's. Here it is. Hello? What were you smoking? All that real estate and only a 2 line display that probably can't be read from 6 feet away, never mind across the room.

Why is it so difficult to put out an affordable home AV mp3 jukebox? Let's see -- hard drive, 4" display, usb and ethernet connection, optical out, OSD, remote control, a half dozen navigation controls. (Except the I/O, actually sounds a lot like a Tivo box!) Am I the only one who would buy this?




ralphb

Comments: 154
Sep 09 (2005) 02:45PM  

Is this thing better than the Nitro Pro Music Server?




ralphb

Comments: 154
Sep 09 (2005) 02:56PM  

Meanwhile, the new Noxon2 will have a USB host, allowing you to play files direct from your MP3 player / memory stick. Whether it lets you download to the MP3 player, I'm not so sure.

It would be great if dapreview could take a look at this device.




dan325it

Comments: 58
Sep 09 (2005) 04:09PM  

Thanks for the link, ralphb. $2500 for the Nitro!! I want 10 of them for that kind of cash.

The Noxon2 has several competitors: Roku Soundbridge and squeezebox2 are two of them. None have on-board storage, though.




vherub

Comments: 30
Sep 09 (2005) 05:10PM  

I can't believe there are only three settings for ripping mp3. Forget about simplicity, as mentioned, you lose people at mp3. I want a device that can easily rip cds at all sorts of settings, flac, ogg, wav, lame mp3, pretty much whatever options you want, with upgradeable firmware to handle anything that pops its head up- streamline these settings and put in a larger drive, because 80 gigs is fast approaching the size of a portable player.




Dark Leth

Comments: 18
Sep 09 (2005) 11:41PM  

MP3 at 320 is okay.

I'd use OGG or something better if my Zen Micro supported it.





deusdiabolus

Comments: 4
Sep 11 (2005) 08:34AM  

This unit makes me think of the Escient Fireball, which also supports one-touch CD to MP3/WAV/FLAC ripping (albeit to store the files on its own internal hard drive). I don't think it allows you to download to a digital device (but it does permit you to do hard drive backups and burns custom CD-Rs), but I'm guessing that's probably their way of staying on the safe side of the RIAA? (It also supports Windows Media Internet stations, but not MP3 ones...for the same reason? Don't know...go figure.)




You must be logged in to make comments on this site - please log in, or if you are not registered click here to signup







User Reviews   Privacy Policy