News   Forum   Reviews   Articles   Where to Shop   Links   Polls   Submit News   DAP Shop   Content  
The Sandisk slotRadio doesn't have a Play button?! [Updated]
comment: 12 | Tuesday, February 10 (2009) 10:28AM | Posted by Michael
I didn't mince any words when I last reported on the slotRadio. I think it's a silly idea and the wrong path for Sandisk to be heading. Now I have more fuel to add to my fire. The slotRadio was recently reviewed by Chip Chick, who discovered that it doesn't have a play button. I know Sandisk is aiming for a device that's so simple my cat can use, but come on. After inserting one of those slotmusic cards pre-loaded with 1,000 billboard toppers, all you can do is just skip forward or backwards. There's also a switch on the side for powering off and switching to FM radio and dedicated buttons on the ptjer side for volume. I just don't get it. Would a dedicated play button really make the device too complicated for its target audience? Even the Sansa Shaker, which was designed for toddlers, has a freaking Play/Pause button.

Summary:

The Good: Smart player for those who want to deviate away from iTunes and the monotony of just being apart of the same iPod crowd. Travel and exercise friendly. Has an LCD display that shows you the songs playing next or at the moment. 1000 songs are a great value.

The Bad: Don’t like that I can’t see the songs preloaded on the microSD card. You could load duplicate songs if you don’t remember what you have on there that was preloaded. Lack of equalizer options.

Since Sandisk is somehow trying to reinvent the radio, maybe their line of thinking was along these lines: "Well you can't pause FM radio so they shouldn't be able to pause slotRadio either!". Sandisk, in the words of Willy Wonka - "You lose! Good day sir!"

Sandisk slotRadio review by Chip Chick

Update: A known member of the Sandisk forums came by to let us know that the slotRadio does have a Pause/Play function. To access it you do the following: "If you press and hold the Skip Button on the side of the device it will pause. Press again and it resumes playback.". Nice to know Sandisk didn't completely lose it!

Thanks lewislink and SansaFix


Comments

Pondlife

Comments: 544
Feb 10 (2009) 10:41AM  

Well it has an off/radio/play switch, as shown in one of the pictures in the review. That seems sufficient really.
[ edited Feb 10 (2009) 10:41AM ]




Michael
Location: New York City
Comments: 2802
Feb 10 (2009) 10:56AM  

I saw the switch, but I don't think it's practical. Should every player be like that? When you want to pause you have to turn off the player? Sure it gets the job done, but ultimately what is the reason for the lack of a dedicated pause button? I really don't see why they couldn't just put one on there like everyone else. We could have the skip track function programmed into that same switch too, that doesn't mean it's a good solution.

[ edited Feb 10 (2009) 10:59AM ]




Pondlife

Comments: 544
Feb 10 (2009) 11:29AM  

It seems like there are far weightier points to count against it than the lack of a pause button, and to be honest I don't use pause anyway. I did think hmmm, stop would make more sense in the centre of the switch though.




Saijin_Naib
Location: Warren, NJ
Comments: 927
Feb 10 (2009) 12:39PM  

The whole device concept is fail, and this just adds one more fail to a whole pile of fail. Oh well.




lewislink
Location: USA
Comments: 70
Feb 10 (2009) 02:05PM  

I'm a DAP enthusiast, and as such I desire all DAPs to exist...only that I had the funds for them - lol...and would love to give this "different" DAP a good ol' check out.

It does have a clip on the back and a nice little screen. If it has the same sound chip as the clip, hmmm.....




Michael
Location: New York City
Comments: 2802
Feb 10 (2009) 02:08PM  

Yeah I do like its design, especially the metal backing and clip.




lewislink
Location: USA
Comments: 70
Feb 10 (2009) 06:37PM  

I think, in a sense, we can be grateful for the Slot Music design. The way I figure it, Sandisk makes memory cards and wants them to sell so they include slots in most of their DAPs that will take their memory cards. How many other DAP makers incorporate cards slots? Not very many. Some that have, are beginning to get away from them too.

Since Sandisk is a memory card maker, they do what they can to sell those cards and will likely continue to include card slots in most of their DAPs. If Sandisk hadn't moved toward the Slot Music system, they might have began to move away from external memory altogether. I don't want that to happen because i like being able to turn a 1GB DAP into a very nice 9GB with an 8GB MicroDSHC. I also want other DAP makers to include card slots, and if the Slot Music system takes off.....




Michael
Location: New York City
Comments: 2802
Feb 10 (2009) 07:01PM  

I don't think anyone is knocking memory slots. It's Sandisk's "new" format called "slotMusic" which I don't particularly care for. slotMusic is being hyped by Sandisk as the new replacement for CD's and even purchasing music online.

See our newspost about it here: [Linky]

They're basically glorified microSD cards with albums on them that sell for like $15 a piece. I just can't get behind something like that.




SansaFix

Comments: 1
Feb 11 (2009) 08:51AM  

Hi Folks,

SansaFix here, some may know me from the SanDisk Forum. If you press and hold the Skip Button on the side of the device it will pause. Press again and it resumes playback.

A short press skips the current song. I hope this helps to clarify things a bit on the SlotRadio Player.

Cheers,

SansaFix




Michael
Location: New York City
Comments: 2802
Feb 11 (2009) 09:02AM  

Thanks very much for that clarification Sansa! I'll make sure to update the post to include it




docpar
Location: NYC
Comments: 68
Feb 11 (2009) 12:09PM  

In my opinion, this whole simple clean idea thats spreading through the market for various products is very bad. I mean, if it is executed well, I dont mind. Executed well means that you can do the same amount of things with the controls as you would be able to with others with more buttons. But this is ridiculous. I think that sandisk is doing this to go with the others who are propogating that clean and simple is always the best. I would rather have the old sandisk players with buttons and relatively cheap looks(but good functionality) compared to this. Same thing is happeneing in computer operating systems. Operating systems in which the user has less control are overtaking those with more user control. Here is the worst example - cars! I think nowadays cars, with their "sleek" and "modern" looks terrible compared to cars of the 70's, 80's, and even the 90's. What is going on?!

or maybe im the only one lol

or maybe




ChipChick
Location: New York
Comments: 1
Feb 19 (2009) 03:18PM  

SansaFix - thanks for letting us all know about that function. We didn't get an instruction manual with our demo unit because it wasn't a final release, so we weren't aware that the function was even there.




You must be logged in to make comments on this site - please log in, or if you are not registered click here to signup








User Reviews   Privacy Policy